Did you know refrigerators are considered the most replaced or serviced appliance in the home, according to appliance repair experts? That makes one more reason why it’s so important to shop for reliable refrigerator brands that provide peace of mind that the next model you choose for your replacement or upgrade doesn’t become a lemon any time soon.
But, often, reliability is synonymous with familiarity. A brand may be well-known, but does that mean they’re good—or are other factors contributing to the popularity? For this article, we put the question to the test with Maytag refrigerators. The brand is one of the biggest domestic names, so how does its lineup of refrigeration measure up? Find out as we give an intro to the brand, followed by three Maytag refrigerator reviews, each from a specific buying category.
At a Glance:
The Ideal Maytag Refrigerator Buyer
Maytag Refrigerator Performance Review
Maytag Refrigerator Pros & Cons
Best Overall Maytag Refrigerator
Best Budget Maytag Refrigerator
Best Luxury Maytag Refrigerator
Who are Maytag Refrigerators Suited For?
For over 100 years, the Maytag brand has been perfecting the craft of consumer appliances, making it one of the most popular names on the market today. Maytag’s slogan, “What’s Inside Matters®,” represents the brand’s dedication to quality engineering. That fine artisanship also comes with a side of patriotism—the majority of Maytag refrigerators manufactured are engineered and built out of the Amana, Iowa headquarters, making Maytag one of the biggest domestic appliance brands available to the public.
The brand was absorbed into the Whirlpool family in 2006, yet the two companies provide individual approaches to their manufacturing, which we detail in our Whirlpool vs. Maytag article. As far as refrigeration goes, compared to Whirlpool, Maytag offers a smaller (yet considerable) lineup of mid-end freestanding refrigerators for the common household. These appliances come in a range of capacities to meet the needs of all buyers—whether your needs are as modest as 18 cubic feet of storage or you require up to 27 cubic feet of volume to feed a full household.
So, how much does a Maytag refrigerator cost? Buyers shopping within a $799–$2,899 price range are highly recommended to explore the Maytag refrigerator line, complete with French door, side-by-side, top-freezer, and bottom-mount models, as well as counter-depth and standard-depth dimensions.
Overall, we recommend these refrigerators to:
∆ Buyers who prefer domestic appliance brands
∆ Shoppers with entry-level to mid-end budgets
∆ Households that don’t require over-the-top refrigeration functions
∆ Users who value a traditional refrigerator experience over new-age refrigeration
Maytag Refrigerator Performance Overview
In terms of performance, we based our Maytag refrigerator reviews on three pillars:
- How well they preserve
- Ease of organization
- Convenience and user experience
Preservation
⊳ PowerCold Feature – With the press of a button, cold air filtered from freezer pumps into the refrigerator to drop temperatures down to 34 degrees. This is handy after restocking or raiding the fridge, but it could also lead to flavor transfer.
⊳ EvenAir Cooling Tower – Specially placed vents throughout the interior deliver optimum air circulation to keeps foods fresher and at ideal temperatures.
⊳ FreshFlow Air Filter – Gases and odors can be harmful to fresh produce. By working 15-times more effective than baking soda, this fresh-air filter reduces spoilage for foods that stay fresher.
⊳ Patented Door Seal Design – Keep cold air in and warm air out with this exclusive door design that provides maximum temperature retention.
Organization
⊳ Slide-out shelf – Unfortunately, this feature is only available on select models. For those fridges, this convertible shelf can slide in or out to provide shelving space instantly.
⊳ Wide-N-Fresh Deli Drawer – This feature (also exclusive to select French door models) provides temperature controls and ample storage ideal for stocking party platters, cakes, and snacks
Convenience
⊳ Store-N-Door feature – This ice dispensing system comes with a removable bin and is relocated to the door for maximum shelf space.
⊳ Fingerprint resistant stainless steel – Enjoy a modern look without outdated cleaning practices. This specially designed finish cleans with just a wipe of water and a towel.
Maytag Refrigerators: Pros and Cons
In the end, we’ve found that Maytag refrigerators fall between two categories: models that come with just simple features that satisfy basic food preservation needs and models with Maytag-exclusive features for an upgraded feel but that aren’t overwhelming. All in all, the experience isn’t the most advanced, but users can expect considerable performance for the value.
Here’s our final tally:
Pros:
✓ 10-year limited parts warranty on the compressor
✓ Affordable starting price
✓ A range of exclusive features
✓ Good selection of refrigerator styles
Cons:
✗ Limited color options (black, white, and stainless steel)
✗ No smart refrigerator models
✗ You pay for features, not capacity
✗ Users have reported issues with ice makers
Our Top Maytag Refrigerator Picks
Here are three outstanding Maytag refrigerators that provide affordable food storage from a reliable name in the business. As always, we take into consideration performance, value, and style too, meaning these three models are complete packages.
Best Overall: Maytag® 20.6 Cu. Ft. Fingerprint Resistant Stainless Steel Counter Depth Side By Side Refrigerator (MSC21C6MFZ)
Neat freezer organization to the left, ample space for stocking fresh food to the right —this Maytag side-by-side refrigerator is a balance of form and function designed for easy food organization. Utilize 20.6 cu. ft. of capacity with a series of shelving, door bins, and humidity-controlled crisper drawers that provide a space for every item on your shopping list. A blast of deep chill with PowerCold technology is ready at your fingertip to protect foods long periods with the door open, whether it’s loading up after grocery shopping or the routine after-school search for snacks.
Positive reviews are also given to this Maytag counter depth refrigerator design that provides a flush look, plus a built-in water and ice dispenser for a touch of luxury.
Best Budget: Maytag® 20.5 Cu. Ft. Black Top Freezer Refrigerator (MRT311FFFE)
Revisit a classic with the top-freezer design of this Maytag standard-capacity refrigerator finished in a fingerprint-resistant finish for a dash of updated style and practicality. The Maytag PowerCold feature goes beyond basic function to shield food from the dangers of temperature swings, bringing the temperature down to 34 degrees when needed. Enjoy even more freshness with crisper drawers equipped with humidity-controlled technology that keep preserve the flavors of produce longer, while a full-width pantry drawer keeps snack items and charcuterie board favorites neatly stored and ready to enjoy.
Best Luxury: Maytag® 24.7 Cu. Ft. Fingerprint Resistant Stainless Steel French Door Refrigerator (MFI2570FEZ)
There’s a reason this Maytag French door refrigerator has earned a 4.5-star rating from over 1,700 product testers. Its combination of modern design, large fridge capacity, and upgraded features give buyers a taste of luxury with a price tag that is also worth savoring. Bulk up on groceries inside 24.7 cu. ft. of storage, plus the handy organization of crispers drawers, wide shelves, and a temperature-controlled pantry drawer. A built-in water and ice dispenser is sure to keep company and the family quenched and refreshed, while the boost of PowerCold temperature regulation ensures every zone inside the refrigerator chamber is just as cool.
Shop Maytag Refrigerators at Albert Lee
The affordability, familiarity, and dependability of Maytag have been recognized for over a century, granting the brand a prestigious spot as one of the more known names on the appliance market. At Albert Lee Appliance, we proudly stock the Maytag brand as part of our complete catalog of home appliances for cooking, refrigeration, dishwashing, and laundry needs because of the value these products offer our shoppers.
Explore everything we have to offer by shopping online, including an In Stock Catalog and Clearance Catalog, or in-store at one of our appliance showrooms across the Seattle area.
Before You Shop: Our Review of Refrigerator Styles